I don’t write much about the PCUSA anymore because it seems to be pointless. Certainly the political activists who dominate the clergy and administration couldn’t care less about their use of Christianity as a means to advance their Leftist political projects. Nor, apparently, do the people in the pews give a hoot about their support of this treachery. No, as long at the leadership maintains the pathetic facade of “Christianity” they will go along pretending that all is well.
But, there comes a point where events have so powerfully exposed the wickedness of it all that something must be said. And, that event is the descent of the Left into overt Nazism with its genocidal antisemitism as seen in our major cities and universities.
For decades the PCUSA leadership has hidden behind the claim that opposition to the existence of the state of Israel is not the direct equivalent of being antisemitic. For example, the General Assembly’s 2015 action to sanction the State of Israel (this is a four-part post series) was claimed to be simply a matter of policy dispute, not an act of antisemitism.
A hopeless optimist might imagine that since 2015 events in the Middle East would have caused the PCUSA’s leadership to have second thoughts. Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact, as this post’s leading image shows, the PCUSA leadership has only increased the viciousness and stupidity of their position. For example, look at this 2022 Christian Post article that covers the overtly antisemitic comments of Rev. Nelson, then head of the PCUSA.
This and many other actions taken by the General Assembly (and many Presbyteries, Sessions, pastors and parishioners) are a stain on the PCUSA. They all have built the deceitful strategy of antisemitism masquerading as anti-Zionism. They will always consider themselves to be our moral, intellectual and spiritual betters – even after their support for antisemitic hatred contributed to this moment of butchery by Hamas.
So, what does the PCUSA elite have to say about the current situation in the Middle East? Well as documented in their article about “Confronting Christian Zionism” they have absolutely nothing to say about the genocidal atrocities by Hanas and its Gaza supporters on October 7, 2023; zero, nada. But they have a lot to say in support of the Palestinians and in opposition of Christian support for Israel.
… the 90-minute session discussed how the Zionism ideology contributes to the violence Palestinians have experienced and the consequences of the settler colonial experience. ,,,
Isaac opened his remarks noting the timeliness of the webinar coinciding with 190 days of continuous war, tens of thousands of deaths — including 14,000 children. “How is it possible the world is at peace with all this? Human rights don’t apply to Palestinians? Do international laws not apply?” he asked. …
Rosen opened his remarks by stating the day’s gathering was amidst an ongoing genocide that needs to be named out loud at every available opportunity. …
“The U.S. is aiding and abetting. This genocide is led by a President who is Catholic but has professed Zionism to his emotional core and has for his entire political career,” said Rosen. “He may not be an evangelical Christian, but he is certainly a Christian Zionist, and I think that’s very important to underline.” …
In light of that, there is another overture coming to this summer’s General Assembly. Confessing Our Complicity on Christian Zionism, sponsored by Muskingum Valley Presbytery, seeks to update and expand on the 2004 resolution. …
“We need to do systemic unpacking and untangling of theology that keeps people hungry and imprisoned — Christian Zionism is a theology that does that,” said Macy. “It closes down and divides us from each other and from opening our hearts in an expansive theological way that recognizes the Divine and all of Creation again.”
The only possible conclusion is that the PCUSA elite supports the Hamas genocidal project. How else could they utterly ignore the atrocities of October 7 while aggressively and openly opposing any Christian support of Israel as “Christian Zoonism”?
But the top prize for utter and complete silence in the face of the Nazi Left’s genocidal antisemitism must go to the Presbytery of New York City. New York City has been the epicenter of Hamas supporting mob protests, including defacement of property, intimidation of Jews, open support of Hamas and blocking of roads and bridges.
And, Columbia University has been the epicenter of the pro-Hamas butchery campus protest movement. The wickedness, hatred, stupidity, aggression and outright delight in genocidal ideation on display at Columbia is beyond any Christian, or human, moral boundary.
Columbia University is in New York City. And, the Presbytery of New York City has absolutely nothing to say about what is going on in their own city.
The figure to the left summarizes the content of the Presbytery of New York’s April 26, 2024 newsletter. I have included a screen shot of every substantive article included in the newsletter. I must ask, do you see anything that even hints at the morally monstrous activities happening right under their noses. The answer is NO.
These are the same people who claim that “silence is violence” if you don’t enthusiastically support their policy positions. Well, it’s time to apply that standard to a Presbytery that is mute in the face of open support of a second Holocaust.
Let’s be honest. The PCUSA elite supports the Hamas project of destroying Israel. They are willing foot soldiers of the antisemitic Iranian totalitarian regime behind it all. And, we, the pew warmers are apparently willing to fund this Leftist project, pretending that we are all just Christ following Christians as the denomination leadership gives moral cover to the most evil ideology ever created in modern times.
This is an absolute disgrace.