What is the Church to Do?
As I have noted the Christian Church cannot exist above the fray of secular politics. However, neither can it allow itself to become a captive of any human ideology or political movement. Tremendous damage has been done by supposed Christian leaders who have come to see the church as a vehicle through which favored secular policies can be pursued. This danger cuts all ways, from Progressive to Conservative and all other ideological categories.
And yet there will be occasions in which a particular secular group’s position is superior to another’s from the Biblical Christian perspective. However, it will never be the case that a secular political group’s policy prescriptions will always be the closest to Biblical Christianity. Since I am currently in a denomination dominated by Progressive politics I have previously explained the absurdity of such an outcome as follows.
What is the likelihood that two organizations, the first driven by the passions and practicalities of contemporary human ideology / politics, and, the second built on Scriptures written by dozens of authors from approximately 1500 B.C. to 100 A.D. concerning the eternal, loving and just God — Father, Son and Holy Spirit — would uniformly arrive at virtually identical moral conclusions and policy prescriptions?
The natural answer for most people would likely be “pretty much zero.” That is, the differences in both the sources and deliberative processes are so vast that it would be absurdly unlikely. And yet, this is the very absurdity upon which most mainline Protestant denominations are built.
That is, we are supposed to accept that the uniform agreement between a human political movement (i.e., Progressive Leftism) and mainline Christian denominations is a natural and credible outcome. But, it is actually an incredible outcome, and one that any committed Christian, regardless of their personal political beliefs should find troubling. Note well that it would be equally incredible and troubling if a Christian denomination uniformly agreed with Conservatism, Libertarianism, or any other secular human movement.
So, what then is the Church to do? My recommendation is to focus first and foremost on the mission that Jesus Christ gave it — that being to preach the Gospel of grace and repentance to a fallen world. The Church is in the primary business of seeking out and saving the lost.
A key component of that mission is to preach and teach the Gospel truth as revealed in the entire Bible. That preaching and teaching should be based on the authority of Scripture, not under the authority of a preselected human ideology. Sometimes one ideological position may appear closer to the Bible than another. In other cases no human ideology will be anywhere close to what God’s Word teaches.
The Church must prayerfully seek to teach the Biblical truth and then let the chips fall where they may. You can count on the church members to discuss and debate how, if at all, this teaching aligns with a given political position. Different members will draw different conclusions.
The point is to equip all members to deliberate on their secular political responsibilities through the application of sound Christian theology and morality. This should not be seen as a means of delivering a uniform political outcome. However, neither can it be acceptable to remain silent when an influential political position clearly violates Christian morality.
In the end we must place our trust in God’s providential action. We will each reason and draw conclusions. Those conclusions will differ in scope, content and force across individuals. If we seek to maintain a Republic consisting of free citizens then our only option is to create a space in which people of very different perspectives can discuss and debate in a humane manner.
If we understand ourselves to all be subject to the power of sin, all to be capable of error, all to be in need of a Savior, then it will be easier to find the humility to seek together towards Truth that lies only within the Mind of our God — Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
For by the grace given me I say to every one of you: Do not think of yourself more highly than you ought, but rather think of yourself with sober judgment, in accordance with the faith God has distributed to each of you. Romans 12:3
If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone. Romans 12:18